The Federal Court of Canada has upheld Blueberry River First Nations Council’s decision to remove former Chief Judy Desjarlais from office.
Desjarlais was removed as chief in September 2024, after an independent investigation determined she had violated the Nation’s bylaws. The court’s decision was rendered in December 2025, after Desjarlais challenged her removal in federal court.
The Court ruled Council’s actions were procedurally fair and reasonable and rejected Desjarlais’ claims the process was politically motivated.
The judge said Desjarlais did not acknowledge the seriousness of her actions, continued to misrepresent the investigation’s findings, and took no responsibility or accountability.
Because of that, the Court found Council had no confidence that she wouldn’t repeat the behaviour—making removal a reasonable and justified sanction.
The ruling followed a 2024 independent investigation that found Desjarlais acted without authority, caused governance issues, and harmed the Nation’s business relationships.
The independent investigation found Desjarlais unilaterally granted oil and gas permit approval to Petronas for work on Blueberry’s land, without obtaining the required approval from council.
We want to be transparent with our members about the outcome of this lengthy legal process so we can close this chapter and begin to heal as a community,” said current Councillor and Chief-Elect, Sherry Dominic.
In the federal court ruling, the judge also noted Desjarlais failed to acknowledge the seriousness of her conduct, making removal a justified sanction. Council says the decision closes a difficult chapter as a newly elected council prepares to take office next week.
“With this matter now resolved, I look forward to Council continuing to work for our members in a respectful and productive way,” added Chief-Elect Dominic